█ _ امال محمد الروبى 0 حصريا كتاب A Response to Patricia Crone s Book Meccan Trade and the Rise of Islam 2024 Islam: In Name Allah Most Gracious, Merciful Introduction Patricia Crone's book of Islam, Oxford, 1987 grabbed my attention, because it tackled an era connected with "The History Arabs before Islam", a course I am teaching female students at the Department History, King Abdul Aziz University, Jeddah It is noteworthy that when started reading through this book, was really shocked by what read between the lines even overtly What me some things were clear, but others grossly incorrect and hidden behind mask fake historical research, the purposes which are obvious for every professional researcher Therefore, as scholar in field, it was necessary respond this so readers will not be deceived misguided great errors introduced them under guise research or scholarship Crone orientalist who raised somewhat clever questions, her answers misleading the time, she deliberately used documented logical coordination order prove opposite has already been proven correct It well known fact that easiest way pass illogical issue make readers swallow begin assumption which looks logical persuasive, fact essentially void Then from false assumption, you jump set of conclusions make your case and acceptable A lies speed at false assumptions passed on skillfully quickly that the reader will pay attention their validity Thus, easily persuaded to accept findings This technique followed historical studies some non objective researchers They insisted on certain idea, idea they look for evidence within context seems persuasive, but lacks validity has changed substituted the words mentioned texts She introduced other detached texts, intentionally ignored sources which contradict opinions; otherwise, would collapse Also, stated conclusions without mentioning the references depended upon Furthermore, she accused orientalists disagreed of trusting Islamic sources despite all their defects This persistent endeavor part aimed at misgiving "Surat Quraysh" Battle Badr" The later, according Holy Qur'an other Islamic sources, took place month Ramadan also changed actual locations; Mecca changed from its geographical location She put Ka'ba North Arabian Peninsula Moreover, claimed Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him (pbuh), appeared "Balqa", farthest North Peninsula, emphasis events related predestined take place South A I examined many fallacies attempt list the most important issues purpose deliberately deceiving study, discussed all these stating main themes follows: First, rejection and geographical facts claiming City Makkah is situated original She moved Makkah map thereby rejecting indications made Greek Roman authors old ages Second, denial Pilgrimage to Makkah (the Ka'ba) before they went three marketplaces near Makkah: Ukaz, Dhul Majaz, Majanna did explain hermitage before and Islam, both cases neglected circamumbation Talbiay pronouncement by Pilgrims during Hajj) cases, she fabricated superficial coordination to prove already She did enough diverse which contradict completely undermine opinion, exploiting lack awareness European readers regarding rituals Third, refuses recognize role Quraysh in international trade Orient insists on marginalizing limiting Quraysh’s local areas Often, about international trade, refrained doing using vague sentences giving any explanation rejected explanations of A Book scholars Surat Quraysh, internationality of Quraysh’s very clear Fourth, mistrusted mission Last Prophet, Muhammad (pbuh) his mission appeared in the to undermine one bases Islamic mission that Quraysh resided Hejaz, Makkah, though undisputable lived مقارنة الأديان مجاناً PDF اونلاين الدين المقارن هو أحد فروع دراسة التي تهتم بالموازنة المنظمة للعقائد والممارسات أديان العالم هذا ركن خاص بالكتب المجانيه مجال وما يتعلق بها